How Many Five-Star Reviews Cancel Out a One-Star Review?
It depends on the average you want to hold. Treat every review as its distance from your target. Aiming for 4.5, a 1-star sits 3.5 below and each 5-star sits 0.5 above, so about seven fives offset one 1-star.
Aiming for 4.0 instead, a 1-star is 3 below and a 5-star is 1 above, so roughly three fives offset it. The higher your target, the more a single bad review costs.
The defence is volume and recency: a business collecting genuine reviews every week barely feels the odd low score.
Related guidesHow Many Google Reviews Do I Need to Reach 4.5 Stars? →How Does Google Calculate a Business’s Star Rating? →Does Google Round Review Ratings Up or Down? →Why Is My Google Rating Not Changing After New Reviews? →